Module 1: The Role of the Reviewer

Learning Objective
Introduction
Video
Readings
Activity

 

Learning Objective

In this module, you’ll review the basics of peer review and learn about the importance it plays in the advancement of science and scholarship. You’ll also explore some criticisms of the traditional methods of peer review and examine some of the emerging alternatives, including open review.

 

Introduction

At its most basic level, peer review involves researchers having their work evaluated by other experts in their discipline. It has played an important role in not only catching errors (or sometimes even outright fabrications) and advancing knowledge, but also in developing the general public’s trust in what we are doing and faith in our methods. In the videos and readings for this module, you’ll learn more about what peer review is, why it is important, and how it may change with the rise of new communication technology.

 

Video

In this first video, How Science Works, Dr. Kevin Padian, Professor of Integrative Biology, explains the scientific peer review process:

In this second video, Kathleen Fitzpatrick, Modern Languages Association, discussions the crucial concept of quality and peer review, with a focus on open review:

 

Readings

 

Activity

How do you see peer review changing in the next decade? Not at all, a little, significantly? Explain why in the comment box below.

Course Home | Next Module →

2 Comments on "Module 1: The Role of the Reviewer"

  1. peer review is way to save science novelty, avoid imitation and plagiarism

  2. Peer review is most important way to develop knowledge and with special state of the art person

Here's your chance to leave a comment!

You must be logged in to post a comment.